← Back to Blog

November 8, 2026

AP English Language 2002 FRQ Response - Kundera & Privacy

My response to a practice FRQ from the 2002 AP English Language discussing Czech writer Milan Kundera's claims about the necessary divide separation between private and public life.

OpinionAP LangEssay

In a passage by Czech writer Milan Kundera, the author claims: “that private and public life are two essentially different worlds and that respect for that difference is the indispensable condition.” In other words, private and public life should be treated as two separate worlds and the “curtain,” as he claims, that separates them should not be tampered with. However, Kundera’s claim is only partially true. While there is an undeniable truth that people will act differently between friends and family compared to strangers and co-workers, individuals cannot expect actions taken in their private lives to not have subsequent consequences that could impact their public lives. If actions are illegal, unethical or significantly harmful to others, then accountability must be held, even if it means intertwining public and private lives and tearing this curtain of separation down.

Private and public life should not always be considered two separate worlds, as is illustrated with the 1970s Nixon Watergate scandal. Following the arrest of a set of operatives who had been hired with setting bugs to record the Democratic National Committee’s offices in the Watergate complex, the true scale of President Nixon and the Republican Party’s wiretapping operation was revealed. In recordings retrieved from Nixon’s private phone conversations, he discussed his actions to cover up such incidents and delay FBI investigations regarding the wiretapping of many of his party's political enemies and journalists. This created a major scandal, leading to Nixon’s resignation prior to the end of his term. While some Nixon’s phone conversations were undoubtedly part of his private, non-public life, they were still taken and used in the investigation that uncovered the Watergate scandal. Kundera could have argued that taking these private conversations was a violation of the separation of private and public life, yet it was necessary. In cases where actions taken in private are illegal, the curtain that separates private and public life must be torn. The argument for protection of confidential and private life, such as Nixon’s phone conversations, cannot be upheld in all cases, especially when accountability is needed. As President of the United States, the general public needed to keep Nixon accountable for his actions, even if that merging his private and public life, and discarding confidentiality; otherwise, Nixon’s involvement may have never been discovered. It is when actions taken in private are themselves illegal, harmful or unethical, or reveal something of similar nature in one’s public life, that Kundera’s argument loses validity—in these cases, in the name of accountability and justice, lives must be merged so that consequences and repercussions may be justly given.

When American energy giant Enron declared bankruptcy in late 2001, its share value collapsed leaving many investors with major losses. Enron employees were left without employment and their company 401(k) plans, which were largely dependent on company stock, essentially ceased to exist. Yet, for the two years leading to the bankruptcy—realizing Enron’s poor financial state—top executives had begun selling their company shares, equating to over 1 billion dollars in revenue. Concurrently, executives had kept general investors and employees in the dark, not telling them the true scale of the company’s financial crisis. Similar to the Watergate scandal, the actions of the company’s top executives had all been done in their private lives. But, in contrast to Watergate, the consequences of these actions had directly impacted more than just a dozen people, instead they directly impacted the thousands of company employees and investors. The dire financial situation and imminent bankruptcy, which executives knew about, had been purposefully kept a secret so that they could sell as many shares and cash out as much as possible. It was fraudulent reporting that led to a sudden and unexpected bankruptcy and subsequently harmed thousands of employees and investors. In cases where private actions can impact so many innocent people, accountability must be restored, even if that means merging private and public lives together. The Enron executives had used their public life knowledge, to make educated decisions in their private lives that impacted thousands of people, hoping to not have their private life actions impact their public life. The private and personal gains of the executives had come at the cost of Enron’s employees and investors, which the executives were directly responsible for in their public roles. Just like a captain of a ship who must ensure the safety of its passengers and cargo, the executives were supposed to ensure the safety of their employees and investors, rather than gain personally. It's because of these illegal and unethical actions that the curtain separating these executives’ private lives needed to be torn apart. The public realized that the executives needed to be held accountable to their actions, and it was the following lawsuits and criminal cases that landed many of the top executives in either federal prison or with millions of dollars in fines. Furthermore, it created a very negative public image for these executives, meaning even following their prison sentences and fines, their unethical and illegal actions scared them forever. The repercussions for their actions had not remained exclusively in their private lives, but instead had impacted their public life, illustrating how these two lives cannot and should not be kept separate at all times.

Removing the divide between private and public lives can allow us to see an individual’s true colors. If a political candidate is claiming to support a certain group (interest group, ethnicity, gender, etc.), yet to his friends and family, in his private life, they admit to not caring about that group’s views and is only making such claims to earn votes, then his prospective constituents deserve to know that candidate’s true motives. When private and public life are kept separate, then there is no way for an individual to be held accountable for the private actions that they take, especially when these actions impact a large number of people. In the case of the political candidates, if that candidate’s constituents knew that the candidate did not actually care about representing their views, then those voters would most likely not want to support him. Keeping both private and public lives intertwined allows the world to see through individuals' poker faces and see their true colors, motives and ideals. Keeping both private and public worlds intertwined allows for accountability, and this becomes especially important when those actions taken impact more than just a small group of people.

That being said, it's true that to some extent privacy must remain a right, especially between both private and public lives. When at home, anyone deserves the right to speak their mind, make a few crude jokes (as Kundera mentions), and potentially vent their frustrations about someone or something to their close friends or family. One’s life should not be recorded 24/7, nor should every action taken be diffused to the public. To this extent, Kundera’s claim remains valid: one's private life deserves some separation and privacy from their public life. The real difference though is when the actions taken in a private life become illegal, unethical, harmful or negatively impact others—regardless of whether the individuals harmed are related to that person’s public or private life. With Enron, executives selling the shares secretly while pretending the company was fine was an example of private actions harming people in the executive’s public lives: the employees and shareholders. Therefore, it's a case for when public and private lives must be merged. A person complaining to their spouse about a terrible boss, isn’t going to directly harm someone, nor is it illegal or unethical, and therefore that person should have the right to have that private discussion remain private and separated from their public life. Fundamentally, humans deserve a right to privacy—one that separates their public and private life; however, when actions taken in one’s private life become harmful, unethical or illegal, then, in the name of justice, accountability and fair consequences, private and public life must be merged and the curtain of separation torn apart.